Cherry Beach doesn't sound like Fucked Up at all, maybe you shouldn't have listened to Fucked Up twice if you didn't want to hear them twice. The original pressing of Cherry Beach is better but repress is still awesome.
I actually love the Cherry Beach reissue, but I can see how people won't be into it. They just recently had a song on the City Limits comp called "Delusional." That song is just a huge boring stinker. Ugh.