Coming to think about it on a larger scale, it's happened more than once. If I look at my starred tracks on Spotify it's pretty horrendous. Annuals, Chapterhouse, Jamie T,Eels and Ride all succumbing to the same fate.
It might be a case of the music actually being really terrible yet the artists got lucky and made a decent track which happens to be the one I like. That's a little pessimistic, and slightly smug since it implies that I have an impeccable ear for music when in fact it's probably only around 90% accurate.
The exception to the rule is The National. Only lately though, may I add. …