British is Better » 讨论

Beatles or Oasis?

 
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 1月 4日, 16:03

    Beatles or Oasis?

    A question that goes on forever with opinons!
    I love both band very much but Oasis was the band who opend my eyes for british music so for me oasis wins in many ways, without oasis I wouldn't listen to Beatles without beatles oasis wouldn't be as good as they was!

    so beatles or oasis for you?

    固定链接  引用

  • are you serious?

    beatles, hands down.

    固定链接  引用

  • are you serious?

    beatles, hands down.

    固定链接  引用
  • I don't really 'get' the beatles, but i haven't really listened to them much. I'm not super into Oasis either, but same goes.

    Oasis wins because spontaneous group singing of Wonderwall is so much fun.

    固定链接  引用
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 1月 7日, 1:07

    2 - 1 to Oasis

    Hey man you think wonderwall is good well i bet you haven't listen to Live Forvere yet!

    固定链接  引用
  • I have absolutely nothing against Oasis but there has never been, nor will be, a band like The Beatles. In my opinion, anyways. So Beatles it is.

    固定链接  引用
    • Ari0n 说...
    • 付费用户
    • 2007年 1月 10日, 16:46
    there has never been, nor will be, a band like The Beatles

    They are just in their own dimension!

    Where were YOU while we were getting high?
    固定链接  引用
    • Alexkrut 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 1月 21日, 11:43
    i_adore_spike said:
    I have absolutely nothing against Oasis but there has never been, nor will be, a band like The Beatles. In my opinion, anyways. So Beatles it is.

    That's true,The Beatles,without any thought.

    固定链接  引用
  • Another point for Oasis!

    I also enjoy The Beatles as well, but I haven't listened to them as I have to Oasis... and I probably got into The Beatles because of Oasis, so, I know it's just my humble opinion, but I'll choose them...

    Wanna get to know me more? http://pablosgonnaliveforever.blogspot.com (en & sp version)



    固定链接  引用
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 1月 25日, 14:44

    4-3 to beatles

    Im glad that oasis atleast are close behind ;)

    固定链接  引用
    • adchelle 说...
    • 付费用户
    • 2007年 1月 26日, 11:44
    i've never liked the beatles. sorry... but look, the world hasn't ended!

    固定链接  引用
  • Primal Scream beats the shit out of oasis. And there is a lot of shit to beat out tbh.

    Moe, moe, kyun!
    固定链接  引用
  • Stone Roses=Pulp>Oasis>Beatles

    my vote is for Oasis though

    固定链接  引用
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 2月 5日, 21:53
    The Beatles. Not even going to dignify the Oasis-philes with a specific response.

    固定链接  引用
    • esc_510 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 2月 11日, 10:12

    i love oasis

    <3 oasis..
    but i enjoy beatles, too.

    固定链接  引用
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 2月 15日, 10:34
    OASIS!!!!

    固定链接  引用
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 2月 17日, 2:46
    I like both, but Beatles.
    Without The Beatles there would be no Oasis, or even rock music as we know it today.

    固定链接  引用
  • im a big Oasis fan myself





    <
    固定链接  引用
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 2月 18日, 18:57

    8 - 6 to Oasis

    seems like we have more oasis fans here :D

    固定链接  引用
    • muzsam 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 3月 17日, 0:03

    Beatles

    Oasis are a good band, but in hindsight there's really no competition, The Beatles hands down!

    固定链接  引用
  • well, im a huge oasis' fan but I think beatles is something really really great which oasis has never reached... anyway, i'm reeeally happy they're close at least. =)

    Wanna get to know me more? http://pablosgonnaliveforever.blogspot.com (en & sp version)



    固定链接  引用
  • storvikarn said:
    A question that goes on forever with opinons!
    I love both band very much but Oasis was the band who opend my eyes for british music so for me oasis wins in many ways, without oasis I wouldn't listen to Beatles without beatles oasis wouldn't be as good as they was!

    so beatles or oasis for you?

    Are you fucking serious? The Beatles slay Oasis!

    固定链接  引用
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 4月 7日, 0:02
    I have listened to every Beatles song or near, and I can understand why they're perceived as a great and influential band. But I really never saw what was that special about them, neither why they're considered greatest band ever. But I saw it immediately with Oasis.

    A Day In The Life ? Hey Jude ? Strawberry Fields Forever ? Oasis released better b-sides.

    Sorry if I'm looking very harsh, I really really really love The Beatles, but I also believe they're way too overrated. If Oasis released songs like The Masterplan, Champagne Supernova and All Around The World back in '62, Noel Gallagher would be up there. Way higher than Lennon. But then, he maybe could not have written these songs if it wasn't for The Beatles. But that's another debate.

    So Oasis hands down for me.

    固定链接  引用
    • [已删除用户] 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 4月 7日, 1:14
    I think Oasis wouldn't be as good as they were if it wasn't for beatles, I mean their first 2 albums was so inspiered by beatles and that's why they are so good, look at oasis now, no feelings in the songs anymore IMAO.

    Oasis have done the most incredible songs like, Live Forever, Champagne Supernova, slide away, All around the world and Rock 'n' Roll Star but overall beatles are the bigger band. If Oasis was born in the 60's they would have got as big as Beatles I think, but the fact is that they are not and if they were they probably would not be as good as they were in the 90's.

    I can't choose between beatles and oasis.

    固定链接  引用
    • BrownPark 说...
    • 用户
    • 2007年 4月 8日, 10:29
    Oasis.

    It echoes in my brain (I didn't mean it)
    Pulses through my veins (I didn't mean it)
    I'm the one to blame (I didn't mean it)
    Did too much cocaine (I didn't mean it)
    固定链接  引用
匿名用户不能张贴消息。请登录或创建账户后再到论坛发帖。