Hard Rock or Heavy Metal?

第 1 页，共 7 页1 2 3 ...7 下一页

- Humppamanne 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 10月 13日, 9:23
Hard Rock or Heavy Metal?

So...is Sabbath a Hard Rock band or a Heavy Metal Band? For me the answer is quiet simple: Hard Rock.
Ok... Iommy sometimes plays a down-tuned guitar, which speaks for heavy metal, but I think it's riffy hard rock. Especially in the first album you can hear the blues influences to Sabbath! And that speaks for hard rock.
What do you think?

[quote][b][user]Humppamanne[/user][/b] 说： So...is Sabbath a Hard Rock band or a Heavy Metal Band? For me the answer is quiet simple: Hard Rock. Ok... Iommy sometimes plays a down-tuned guitar, which speaks for heavy metal, but I think it's riffy hard rock. Especially in the first album you can hear the blues influences to Sabbath! And that speaks for hard rock. What do you think?[/quote]

固定链接引用
- billsd 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 10月 16日, 2:23
I consider them heavy metal, personally. I think the guitar sound Iommi could pull off was more recognized in heavy metal over hard rock. When I think hard rock, I think Deep Purple or AC/DC. Black Sabbath is a bit heavier than them in my opinion.

Still, a great question; took some thought to answer.

[quote][b][user]billsd[/user][/b] 说： I consider them heavy metal, personally. I think the guitar sound Iommi could pull off was more recognized in heavy metal over hard rock. When I think hard rock, I think Deep Purple or AC/DC. Black Sabbath is a bit heavier than them in my opinion. Still, a great question; took some thought to answer.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- -Reaper- 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 10月 25日, 14:45
If you think that BS is Hard Rock than you do not know what Black Sabbath is, nor do you know what Metal is. Black Sabbath are the first Heavy Metal band. No questions asked. Of course the definition of Metal has changed over the years, but Black Sabbath's metalness is timeless and unlike other "metal" bands of the 70s, that were deemed as such by ignorant media folk due to the "down tuned" guitar sound, BS were and are still Metal by even today's definition.

Go listen to Tyr, Mob Rules, Heaven and Hell or Mob Rules. Definitive Power Metal music of the 80s, obviously Power Metal only of the mid 80s, hence it's heavy metal (a sub-genre of Metal) by definition, I'm not talking about Hammerfall Power Metal here, more in line with Angel Witch Power Metal, which by today's definition wouldn't be Power Metal.

Assailants propagate the schism
Black metal will continue; as long as Judeo-Christian ideals exist,
so will the need to oppose them with art.
Death Metal Black Metal The Antichristian Phenomenon
Truest Metal Fans Porn Request underground BM here

[quote][b][user]-Reaper-[/user][/b] 说： If you think that BS is Hard Rock than you do not know what Black Sabbath is, nor do you know what Metal is. Black Sabbath are the first Heavy Metal band. No questions asked. Of course the definition of Metal has changed over the years, but Black Sabbath's metalness is timeless and unlike other "metal" bands of the 70s, that were deemed as such by ignorant media folk due to the "down tuned" guitar sound, BS were and are still Metal by even today's definition. Go listen to Tyr, Mob Rules, Heaven and Hell or Mob Rules. Definitive Power Metal music of the 80s, obviously Power Metal only of the mid 80s, hence it's heavy metal (a sub-genre of Metal) by definition, I'm not talking about Hammerfall Power Metal here, more in line with Angel Witch Power Metal, which by today's definition wouldn't be Power Metal.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- badinsults 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 10月 27日, 1:25
Technically, the first band that was described as heavy metal was Steppenwolf in 1968 when their hit Born To Be Wild came out. If Steppenwolf was heavy metal, then I would describe Black Sabbath has heavier metal. haha, I jest. Read up on the history.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_metal_music

DIO \m/

[quote][b][user]badinsults[/user][/b] 说： Technically, the first band that was described as heavy metal was Steppenwolf in 1968 when their hit Born To Be Wild came out. If Steppenwolf was heavy metal, then I would describe Black Sabbath has heavier metal. haha, I jest. Read up on the history. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_metal_music[/quote]

固定链接引用
- -Reaper- 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 10月 28日, 7:17
Wikipedia cannot be trusted when discussing and documenting issues such as Heavy Metal because the media, or the populus in general, cannot be asked to distinguish between genres of music, especially when it comes to Metal.

Assailants propagate the schism
Black metal will continue; as long as Judeo-Christian ideals exist,
so will the need to oppose them with art.
Death Metal Black Metal The Antichristian Phenomenon
Truest Metal Fans Porn Request underground BM here

[quote][b][user]-Reaper-[/user][/b] 说： Wikipedia cannot be trusted when discussing and documenting issues such as Heavy Metal because the media, or the populus in general, cannot be asked to distinguish between genres of music, especially when it comes to Metal.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- badinsults 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 10月 29日, 6:52
If the populous in general cannot be asked to distinguish between genres of music, then who can? It would be rather arrogant to say that only a select few are "leet" enough to judge such things.

DIO \m/

[quote][b][user]badinsults[/user][/b] 说： If the populous in general cannot be asked to distinguish between genres of music, then who can? It would be rather arrogant to say that only a select few are "leet" enough to judge such things.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- -Reaper- 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 10月 30日, 0:46
Not a select few, but at least the Metal crowd who know the intrinsic nature of Metal. The self-proclaimed rock historians and pseudo-intellectual rock music experts of wikipedia and the rock and roll hall of fame know nothing of what Metal is really about and how to classify it. That is what I meant.

Assailants propagate the schism
Black metal will continue; as long as Judeo-Christian ideals exist,
so will the need to oppose them with art.
Death Metal Black Metal The Antichristian Phenomenon
Truest Metal Fans Porn Request underground BM here

[quote][b][user]-Reaper-[/user][/b] 说： Not a select few, but at least the Metal crowd who know the intrinsic nature of Metal. The self-proclaimed rock historians and pseudo-intellectual rock music experts of wikipedia and the rock and roll hall of fame know nothing of what Metal is really about and how to classify it. That is what I meant.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- scottwallace01 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 10月 30日, 3:08
Iommi claims he never considered them a metal band. Then again, when you practically invent something, the terminology comes along later.

They play enough bluesy stuff on the early albums to be a hard rock band, but their overall sound was too inspirational to metal for them to TRULY be considered hard rock. A metal band can write hard rock songs, and vice versa.

Really, the questions should be what genre of metal Sabbath truly is! So inspirational for Doom and Sludge, but the Tony Martin era has a very power metal feel to it. Despite the fact that so many say "Sabbath is a grea metal band," they're really tough to classify. Doesn't matter, though, because it's all fucking killer stuff.

My Top Albums:

♪ GN'R ♪ AC/DC ♪ Sabbath ♪ Led Zep ♪ Maiden ♪ Slash ♪ Izzy ♪ Duff ♪ Crüe ♪
♪ ♪ ♪Classic Rock ♪ Hard Rock ♪ True Metal ♪ Melodic Death♪
♪Sleaze ♪ Hair ♪ I Buy CDs ♪

[quote][b][user]scottwallace01[/user][/b] 说： Iommi claims he never considered them a metal band. Then again, when you practically invent something, the terminology comes along later. They play enough bluesy stuff on the early albums to be a hard rock band, but their overall sound was too inspirational to metal for them to TRULY be considered hard rock. A metal band can write hard rock songs, and vice versa. Really, the questions should be what genre of metal Sabbath truly is! So inspirational for Doom and Sludge, but the Tony Martin era has a very power metal feel to it. Despite the fact that so many say "Sabbath is a grea metal band," they're really tough to classify. Doesn't matter, though, because it's all fucking killer stuff.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- _Tarkus_ 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 11月 4日, 7:34
Heavy Metal for sure, though I generally tag them Classic Metal - a combination of Classic Rock and Heavy Metal, I suppose.

[ Emerson, Lake & Palmer | Frank Marino & Mahogany Rush | King Crimson | Rush ]
[ King's X | Las Vegas | Atlanta Braves | Kansas City Chiefs | Family Guy | Group Owners ]

[quote][b][user]_Tarkus_[/user][/b] 说： Heavy Metal for sure, though I generally tag them Classic Metal - a combination of Classic Rock and Heavy Metal, I suppose.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- seltsame_person 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 11月 6日, 21:55
neither..nor

I guess this is one of the most difficult questions in the world. To me, sabbath is an absolute hard rock band, but they were also the first band who started to use dark sounding riffs combined with dark/ evil lyrics. So to me, they were also the "founders" of metal.

[quote][b][user]seltsame_person[/user][/b] 说： I guess this is one of the most difficult questions in the world. To me, sabbath is an absolute hard rock band, but they were also the first band who started to use dark sounding riffs combined with dark/ evil lyrics. So to me, they were also the "founders" of metal.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- ANDROPENIS 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 11月 17日, 0:29
To me they are simply a kick ass rock band.The great thing about Sabbath is the fact that they werent conscious they were defining a new genre, they were just doing their thing.

"I HATE COMMERCIAL MUSIC,IN FACT I HATE ALMOST EVERYTHING"

(CONFUCIUS, 3500 BC)

[quote][b][user]ANDROPENIS[/user][/b] 说： To me they are simply a kick ass rock band.The great thing about Sabbath is the fact that they werent conscious they were defining a new genre, they were just doing their thing.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- Saf_1 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 11月 24日, 23:12
[spam]

[spam]

'Scuse me while i kiss the sky♫

[quote][b][user]Saf_1[/user][/b] 说： [spam][/quote]
由 hjbardenhagen 在 2011年 1月 3日, 16:42 编辑

固定链接引用
- Bumblebee22 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 11月 26日, 10:29
Metal.

[quote][b][user]Bumblebee22[/user][/b] 说： Metal.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- ArthonX 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 11月 27日, 13:23
Personally,i consider Sabbath beign the fathers of Doom Metal ;)

[quote][b][user]ArthonX[/user][/b] 说： Personally,i consider Sabbath beign the fathers of Doom Metal ;)[/quote]

固定链接引用
- [已删除用户] 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 12月 17日, 10:00
I consider Sabbath to be Heavy Rock because they have heavier songs like Black Sabbath but they also have softer songs like Hard Road.

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] 说： I consider Sabbath to be Heavy Rock because they have heavier songs like Black Sabbath but they also have softer songs like Hard Road.[/quote]

固定链接引用
- Saf_1 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 12月 19日, 19:48
[spam]

[spam]

'Scuse me while i kiss the sky♫

[quote][b][user]Saf_1[/user][/b] 说： [spam][/quote]
由 hjbardenhagen 在 2011年 1月 3日, 16:42 编辑

固定链接引用
- annoxero 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 12月 19日, 22:11
a mix of both imo. there were both hard rock stuff and heavy metal in it

[quote][b][user]annoxero[/user][/b] 说： a mix of both imo. there were both hard rock stuff and heavy metal in it[/quote]

固定链接引用
- honcuk 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 12月 22日, 22:09
I think that the early sabs definitely are:

post-blues / proto-stoner / proto-doom / proto-heavy metaly / hard rock band !!!

Martin era definitely is:

(pop) power/doom metal (they're too slow to be power metal and some osngs definitely are doomiest they've ever written - Virtual Death or Eternal Idol to name some ...

and this era is great also !

[quote][b][user]honcuk[/user][/b] 说： I think that the early sabs definitely are: post-blues / proto-stoner / proto-doom / proto-heavy metaly / hard rock band !!! Martin era definitely is: (pop) power/doom metal (they're too slow to be power metal and some osngs definitely are doomiest they've ever written - Virtual Death or Eternal Idol to name some ... and this era is great also ![/quote]

固定链接引用
- Hagorr 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 12月 24日, 22:28
For me, definitely a heavy metal band. I don't really care for technical explanations, some songs are bluesy, some are classical rock, other have more metal in themselves than whole discographies by other bands have... What counts in my opinions is the general atmosphere they create when listened to. And with no doubt it's heavy metal if you ask me :]

Artificial intelligence is no match for natural stupidity.

[quote][b][user]Hagorr[/user][/b] 说： For me, definitely a heavy metal band. I don't really care for technical explanations, some songs are bluesy, some are classical rock, other have more metal in themselves than whole discographies by other bands have... What counts in my opinions is the general atmosphere they create when listened to. And with no doubt it's heavy metal if you ask me :][/quote]

固定链接引用
- Arnold_Laynebr 说...
- 用户
- 2006年 12月 25日, 18:00
Hard rock = 60´s and early 70´s....heavy metal=80´s

[quote][b][user]Arnold_Laynebr[/user][/b] 说： Hard rock = 60´s and early 70´s....heavy metal=80´s[/quote]

固定链接引用
- [已删除用户] 说...
- 用户
- 2007年 1月 7日, 2:23
both are right - even Sabbs have lots of reall doom metal songs!

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] 说： both are right - even Sabbs have lots of reall doom metal songs![/quote]

固定链接引用
- SabianHo 说...
- 用户
- 2007年 1月 15日, 0:03
Heavy Metal for sure - They started it all.

[quote][b][user]SabianHo[/user][/b] 说： Heavy Metal for sure - They started it all. [/quote]

固定链接引用
- BlackSabbath86 说...
- 用户
- 2007年 2月 5日, 12:27
Who cares, so long as you enjoy it! :)

Buried Sleeper @ LastFM
Buried Sleeper @ Facebook
Buried Sleeper @ BandCamp

[quote][b][user]BlackSabbath86[/user][/b] 说： Who cares, so long as you enjoy it! :)[/quote]

固定链接引用
- [已删除用户] 说...
- 用户
- 2007年 2月 9日, 15:21
In my opinion it depends what album (song) you mean. Sabbath Bloody Sabbath is heavy metal album at all, istn it? But as songs as "iron man", "paranoid", "war pigs" have hard rock (even rock-and-roll :|) sound. I love black sabbath with they heavy metal sound, but they are gods at all! :D

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] 说： In my opinion it depends what album (song) you mean. Sabbath Bloody Sabbath is heavy metal album at all, istn it? But as songs as "iron man", "paranoid", "war pigs" have hard rock (even rock-and-roll :|) sound. I love black sabbath with they heavy metal sound, but they are gods at all! :D[/quote]

固定链接引用
- witheredpotato 说...
- 用户
- 2007年 2月 21日, 12:05
black sabbath created metal,but also had a couplwe og hard rock/blues songs(the wizard,warning), a bit of jazz(rat salad) psychedelic rock(planet caravan) i think mainly metal but other genres are in there songs too

A Mish Mash Of Ignorance Brought to You By witheredpotato

[quote][b][user]witheredpotato[/user][/b] 说： black sabbath created metal,but also had a couplwe og hard rock/blues songs(the wizard,warning), a bit of jazz(rat salad) psychedelic rock(planet caravan) i think mainly metal but other genres are in there songs too[/quote]

固定链接引用